Practical guide
ISO 9001 clause 8.4: control of externally provided processes, products and services
ISO 9001 clause 8.4 explained: what 8.4.1, 8.4.2 and 8.4.3 require for suppliers, which records you need, what AS9100 adds and what auditors check.
ISO 9001:2015 clause 8.4 covers everything you buy in that affects your product or service: material, parts, outsourced processes and services. It requires you to evaluate and select suppliers (“external providers”), to control what they deliver in proportion to the risk, and to give them clear requirements. This page explains each sub-clause in practical terms. It paraphrases the standard; for the exact wording, refer to the standard itself.
When clause 8.4 applies
Clause 8.4 applies to externally provided processes, products and services when:
- they are incorporated into your own products and services (material, components),
- they are provided directly to your customers on your behalf (for example drop-shipped parts),
- a process is outsourced to an external provider as a result of your decision (heat treatment, coating, calibration, design work).
Outsourcing a process does not outsource the responsibility: you remain responsible for the conformity of what your customer receives.
8.4.1 General: evaluation, selection, monitoring, re-evaluation
You must ensure that what external providers deliver conforms to requirements. In practice, 8.4.1 asks you to:
- determine and apply criteria for the evaluation, selection, monitoring of performance and re-evaluation of external providers, based on their ability to deliver according to your requirements,
- retain documented information of these activities and of any actions arising from the evaluations.
What this means in practice:
| Requirement | Typical implementation |
|---|---|
| Criteria for evaluation and selection | Procedure with criteria, e.g. samples, certificates, audit, references |
| Monitoring of performance | Delivery reliability, non-conformances, complaint handling |
| Re-evaluation | Periodic supplier evaluation with a score and grade |
| Records of results and actions | Evaluation forms, approved supplier list, action records |
The standard does not prescribe a method or frequency. A weighted scoring model like the one in our calculator is one common way to meet it.
8.4.2 Type and extent of control
The control you apply should match the risk. 8.4.2 asks you to:
- ensure that outsourced processes remain within the control of your quality management system,
- define the controls you apply to the provider and to the resulting output,
- take into account the potential impact of what is supplied on your ability to meet customer and legal requirements, and the effectiveness of the controls the provider applies itself,
- determine the verification (for example incoming inspection) needed to ensure the supplied output meets requirements.
In practice: a certified stockholder supplying standard material with 3.1 certificates may need a certificate check; a new supplier of safety-relevant machined parts may need first article inspection, an audit and sample inspection of every delivery.
8.4.3 Information for external providers
Your suppliers can only meet requirements you have communicated. Before you send them, you must make sure the requirements are adequate. 8.4.3 lists what to communicate, including:
- the processes, products and services to be provided,
- the approval of products and services, methods, processes and equipment, and the release of products and services,
- competence, including any required qualification of persons,
- the provider’s interactions with your organisation,
- the control and monitoring of the provider’s performance that you will apply,
- verification or validation activities you or your customer intend to perform at the provider’s premises.
Typical vehicles: the purchase order with drawing and specification references, a quality assurance agreement, and supplier requirements in a supplier manual.
Documented information you need
- Criteria for evaluation, selection, monitoring and re-evaluation (procedure)
- Records of evaluations and resulting actions
- Approved supplier list or equivalent register (practically necessary, explicitly required in AS/EN 9100)
- Purchase documents with the communicated requirements
- Verification records (incoming inspection, certificates)
What AS/EN 9100 adds
AS/EN 9100 (aerospace) keeps the ISO 9001 text and adds requirements. Among others:
- a register of external providers with approval status and scope of approval,
- periodic review of provider performance, including process performance, product quality and on-time delivery,
- risk identification and management for external providers,
- responsibility for conformity including customer-designated sources,
- actions when providers do not meet requirements,
- extended information for providers (8.4.3), for example: flowing requirements down to sub-tier suppliers, right of access for you, your customer and authorities, notification of nonconforming product and of changes to processes, products or locations, prevention of counterfeit parts, test specimens, record retention, and awareness of product safety and ethical behaviour.
What auditors check under 8.4
- Are evaluation criteria defined and actually applied to all relevant suppliers, including outsourced processes and service providers?
- Are poor results followed by actions?
- Does the extent of control match the risk (or does every supplier get the same, minimal control)?
- Do purchase documents contain the necessary requirements?
- Is verification of supplied products documented?
Findings on 8.4 I have seen in audits, anonymized:
- A supplier on the approved list without an initial assessment. Nobody had checked the company’s history, financial situation or certificates before the first order.
- The same criteria for every type of supplier. The criteria were defined, but not suited to the supplier: a service provider was scored on product quality questions. Categories with their own criteria fix this, and they also answer the auditor’s question whether the extent of control matches the risk.
Checklist: meeting clause 8.4
- Procedure with criteria for evaluation, selection, monitoring and re-evaluation
- All relevant suppliers identified (material, parts, outsourced processes, services)
- Initial evaluation for new suppliers, documented
- Periodic evaluation with documented results and actions
- Approved supplier list with status (and scope, for AS/EN 9100)
- Controls defined per supplier type and risk
- Requirements communicated in purchase documents or quality agreements
- Verification of supplied products recorded
FAQ
Does ISO 9001 require an approved supplier list?
Not by name. It requires criteria and records of evaluation and selection; an approved supplier list is the usual way to show the result. AS/EN 9100 does require a register with approval status.
How often must suppliers be re-evaluated under ISO 9001?
The standard does not set a frequency. Define one in your procedure based on risk; at least yearly for suppliers that affect product quality is common.
Do service providers fall under 8.4?
Yes, if their service affects the conformity of your products or services, for example calibration, testing, transport of sensitive goods or outsourced design.