Practical resource hub

Supplier evaluation: how to evaluate suppliers, step by step

How to evaluate suppliers: criteria, weighted scoring, A/B/C grades and what ISO 9001 and AS9100 require. With a worked example and free template.

Written by , Head of Quality (AS/EN 9100)

Updated:

Grounded in practiceWritten for real quality work
Ready to applyUse examples, templates, and clear steps
Useful next stepsConnected to relevant tools and guides

Supplier evaluation is the systematic assessment of whether a supplier can deliver what you need: the right quality, on time, under control. You do it before you approve a new supplier and regularly afterwards, based on criteria you define, and you act on the result. ISO 9001 (clause 8.4.1) and AS/EN 9100 require it; done well, it is also the best early warning system you have.

This guide shows the whole method as we use it in an AS/EN 9100-certified company: the criteria, how to weight and score them, how to turn the score into an A/B/C grade and a decision, and what auditors look for. You can try every step with the free supplier evaluation calculator or the Excel template.

Evaluation, assessment, audit, selection: what is the difference?

The terms are used loosely. In a quality system it helps to keep them apart:

Term When Question it answers Typical output
Supplier selection Before the first order Which of several candidates should we use? Shortlist, decision
Supplier assessment / qualification Before approval Is this supplier able to meet our requirements at all? Approved / conditionally approved / not approved
Supplier audit Before approval or when problems occur Does the supplier’s system work in practice, on site? Audit report, findings
Supplier evaluation (performance evaluation) Regularly during the relationship How well has the supplier actually performed? Score, A/B/C grade, actions
Re-evaluation Periodically, or after an event Is the approval still justified? Confirmed, conditional or withdrawn approval

An audit is one input to an evaluation, not a replacement for it. A good evaluation combines what you know before the relationship (certificates, samples, audit result) with what you measure during it (delivery reliability, non-conformances, communication).

What ISO 9001 and AS/EN 9100 require

ISO 9001:2015, clause 8.4.1 asks you to determine and apply criteria for the evaluation, selection, monitoring of performance and re-evaluation of external providers, based on their ability to deliver according to your requirements. You must keep documented information of these activities and of any actions arising from the evaluations.

The standard does not prescribe a method. A weighted score is not mandatory, but you need criteria that are defined in advance, applied consistently and documented.

AS/EN 9100 (aerospace) adds to this. Among other things, you are expected to:

  • maintain a register of external providers with their approval status (for example approved, conditional, disapproved) and the scope of the approval,
  • periodically review supplier performance, including process performance, product quality and on-time delivery,
  • define what happens when a supplier does not meet requirements,
  • identify and manage the risks associated with external providers.

In practice this means an approved supplier list that is driven by evaluation results, not maintained by hand. See ISO 9001 clause 8.4 explained for the requirement in detail.

What auditors find

Findings I have seen in audits on supplier evaluation, anonymized:

  • No initial assessment. A supplier was added to the approved supplier list without one. An initial assessment checks, for example, how long the company has existed, its financial situation and which certificates it holds, so you limit your own risk before the first order.
  • One set of criteria for every supplier. A raw material supplier, a heat-treatment shop and a calibration service were all scored on the same questions. Group suppliers into categories and set the criteria for each.
  • Non-conformances barely affect the score. The auditor asks what drives the grade. If complaints are not one of the big factors, the evaluation does not reflect real performance.
  • The wrong person evaluates. The evaluation should be done by someone who works with the supplier and has the data: non-conformances, delivery dates kept, quality of parts and documents.

The criteria: what to evaluate

Evaluate what really predicts whether a supplier will cause you problems. A proven structure has four groups. These are the 15 criteria we use (also built into the calculator and the template):

Group Criterion Default weight
Product / service quality Sample quality (first article) 13.34 %
Material certificates 13.34 %
References 13.34 %
Technical capability 10 %
Quality system Certified management system (ISO 9001 / 14001) 5 %
Supplier audit result 5 %
Site visit 5 %
Feedback from the supplier’s other customers 5 %
Delivery and cooperation On-time delivery 5 %
Payment terms 3.33 %
Complaint handling 3.33 %
Communication 3.33 %
Non-conformances (calculated) Number and severity of non-conformances 6 %
Non-conformances closed on time 5 %
8D response quality 4 %

Two design choices matter more than the exact list:

  1. Product quality carries the most weight. A supplier with excellent paperwork and late, defective parts is still a bad supplier.
  2. Non-conformances are calculated, not estimated. The last group is computed from your complaint records, so the evaluation reflects what actually happened instead of how the evaluator feels about the supplier.

You will find the criteria explained one by one, with scoring guidance for 0, 50 and 100 points, in supplier evaluation criteria.

What about the “10 C’s”? The 10 C’s of supplier evaluation (competency, capacity, commitment, control, cash, cost, consistency, culture, clean, communication) are a useful checklist when you select a new supplier. For the ongoing evaluation that ISO 9001 asks for, measurable criteria like the ones above work better, because they can be scored the same way every time.

How to score: weighted points and A/B/C grades

Each criterion is scored from 0 to 100 and multiplied by its weight. The sum is the supplier’s total score, also from 0 to 100:

Total score = Σ (score × weight)

The total is then translated into a grade:

Grade Score Meaning Typical action
A ≥ 90 Excellent supplier Keep the partnership, consider for new business
B 71–89 Good supplier Monitor, agree on improvements for weak criteria
C ≤ 70 Unsatisfactory Corrective action plan, conditional approval, look for alternatives

Non-conformances lower the score

A score only from questionnaires tends to stay flat for years. That is why each non-conformance in the evaluation period reduces the score of the area it affected: 15 points for a critical, 8 for a major and 3 for a minor non-conformance, at most 30 points per area, spread over the criteria of that area by weight. A delivery problem therefore lowers the delivery criteria, not product quality.

Worked example

A machined-parts supplier is evaluated after 12 months. The scores per criterion:

Group Scores Points without NCs
Product / service quality samples 90, certificates 100, references 80, technical capability 70 43.02
Quality system certification 100, audit 85, site visit 80, customer feedback 70 16.75
Delivery and cooperation on time 88, payment terms 100, complaints 60, communication 70 12.06
Non-conformances no non-conformances: 100 / 100 / 100 15.00
Total 86.83 → grade B

During the period there were two non-conformances: one major in product quality (closed on time, with a complete 8D report) and one minor in delivery (closed late, no 8D). The product criteria lose 8 points in total, the delivery criteria 3, and the three calculated criteria drop to 70, 50 and 50. The total falls to 79.4: still B, but with a clear message about where the supplier needs to improve.

You can reproduce this example in the supplier evaluation calculator.

Step by step: running a supplier evaluation

  1. Define the scope. Which suppliers are evaluated? Start with those whose products or services affect your product quality: material, parts, outsourced processes, calibration and testing services.
  2. Fix criteria, weights and grade limits in a procedure. Write them down once; auditors check that you apply what you defined.
  3. Collect the data. Delivery performance from purchasing or ERP, non-conformances from your complaint records, audit results from the audit reports. Ask the people who work with the supplier for the qualitative criteria.
  4. Score and grade. Use one form for all suppliers: an evaluation template, the calculator or software.
  5. Decide and act. Update the approved supplier list, agree on actions with B and C suppliers, and document the decisions.
  6. Communicate the result to the supplier. A short supplier scorecard with the score, the weak criteria and the expected improvements works better than a letter.
  7. Repeat. Re-evaluate periodically and whenever something important happens.

A more detailed version with responsibilities and records is in supplier evaluation process.

New supplier evaluation vs. re-evaluation

For a new supplier, you have no performance history. The evaluation relies on samples, certificates, references, a site visit or an audit, and the result decides whether the supplier is approved, approved with conditions, or rejected.

For an existing supplier, the performance data takes over: delivery reliability, non-conformances and how they were handled. A practical rhythm:

  • at least once a year for every supplier that affects product quality,
  • additionally after a critical non-conformance, a change of the supplier’s site, process or ownership, or a long break in deliveries.

ISO 9001 does not prescribe how often. Once a year is the common workflow, and it has a side effect worth having: it reminds the supplier that you measure their performance. Decide in your procedure whether a non-conformance triggers an extra evaluation, and which ones. You define what counts as a non-conformance and how much each criterion weighs, so the system works the way your risks require. Used like that, the evaluation keeps an eye on every supplier’s performance and makes clear that you expect good products and service.

What to do with the result

The score is only useful if it leads to a decision:

  • A suppliers: confirm the approval. Use them as references and consider them first for new parts.
  • B suppliers: discuss the two or three weakest criteria with the supplier and agree on concrete improvements with dates.
  • C suppliers: request a corrective action plan, set the approval to conditional, increase incoming inspection and, if nothing improves, start qualifying an alternative.

Decide this before the first evaluation, in your procedure: what happens when a supplier falls to C. A C means the supplier does not perform as you expect, and the response should not be improvised.

In every case, tell the supplier the result: how you rated them, which criteria you used, how they scored on each, and what they need to do to improve. An evaluation the supplier never sees changes nothing.

When a supplier falls to C, consider an audit at their site to see what is really going on. Sometimes it is a communication problem, sometimes something more serious. You can also hold back new business until the supplier answers the corrective actions you requested after the evaluation.

If you are new to supplier evaluation, also check your own model: a lot of C grades in the first round can mean the weights or criteria are too strict, not that the suppliers are bad.

Common mistakes

  • Everyone gets an A. If 95 % of your suppliers are A, the criteria do not discriminate. Check whether non-conformances actually reduce the score. For comparison, our own distribution with this model: of the 98 suppliers we evaluate, 43 are A (44 %), 52 are B (53 %) and 3 are C (3 %). A healthy spread has a clear group that needs attention, and every C needs a documented action.
  • The evaluation never changes anything. Auditors look for actions taken on poor results. A C grade without a documented action is a typical finding.
  • Only material suppliers are evaluated. Outsourced processes (heat treatment, coating), calibration labs and test labs affect product quality too.
  • Copying last year’s spreadsheet. If the scores are identical every year, the evaluation is not based on data.
  • Complaints are not connected to the evaluation. The non-conformances of the period are the most objective information you have.

Templates and tools

FAQ

Is supplier evaluation mandatory under ISO 9001?

Yes. Clause 8.4.1 requires criteria for the evaluation, selection, performance monitoring and re-evaluation of external providers, and records of the results and resulting actions. The method is up to you.

How often should suppliers be evaluated?

The standards do not set a frequency. At least once a year for suppliers that affect product quality is common practice, plus an extra evaluation after critical non-conformances or significant changes at the supplier.

Who should evaluate suppliers?

Quality management usually owns the process, but the data comes from several functions: purchasing (prices, terms, communication), logistics (delivery reliability), quality (non-conformances, audits) and production (practical experience with the parts).

What is the difference between a supplier scorecard and a supplier evaluation?

The evaluation is your internal assessment and decision. The scorecard is the summary you share with the supplier to show where they stand and what to improve.

Can a small company keep it simple?

Yes. A single form with a handful of weighted criteria, applied to all relevant suppliers once a year, with documented actions for poor results, meets the requirement. The Excel template is designed for exactly that.

Explore this topic