Free template
Non-conformance report (NCR): template, example and process
What a non-conformance report (NCR) must contain, a field-by-field template, a filled-in example, disposition options and how the NCR leads to an 8D.
Non-conformance report (NCR) form
Every field from this page: identification, part and source, requirement and actual, severity, containment, disposition with approval, corrective action and closure. Editable Word file.
No signup requiredA non-conformance report (NCR) records that a product, material or service did not meet its requirements: what is wrong, how many parts are affected, what happens to them, and whether a corrective action is needed. It is the first document in every quality problem; the corrective action request and the 8D report build on it.
What an NCR must contain
| Field | Content |
|---|---|
| NCR number and date | Unique number for traceability |
| Detected by / where | Person and stage: incoming inspection, production, final inspection, customer |
| Part / material | Part number, name, drawing revision, lot or batch, order or delivery note |
| Source | Supplier, internal process or customer return |
| Quantity | Quantity inspected, quantity nonconforming |
| Requirement | What the drawing, specification or order requires |
| Actual | What was found, with measured values |
| Evidence | Photos, measurement report, sample |
| Severity | Critical, major or minor (defined in your procedure) |
| Containment | Parts blocked, where, by whom |
| Disposition | Decision on the nonconforming parts (see below), with approval |
| Corrective action required? | Yes / no; if yes, reference to 8D or SCAR |
| Closure | Date, name, verification that the disposition was carried out |
Disposition options
| Disposition | Meaning | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Return to supplier | Parts go back for replacement or credit | Usually combined with a SCAR |
| Rework | Parts are brought into conformity by an approved process | Re-inspect after rework |
| Repair | Parts are made usable but not fully conforming | Often requires customer approval |
| Use as is (concession) | Parts are used despite the deviation | In aerospace and other regulated industries, customer or design-authority approval is usually required |
| Scrap | Parts are destroyed | Make sure they cannot re-enter production |
Example
| NCR | NCR-2026-047, 2 October |
| Detected | Incoming inspection, inspector J. Doe |
| Part | A-4711 housing, drawing rev. C, lot 2391, delivery note 88213 |
| Source | Supplier: machined parts supplier (example) |
| Quantity | 50 inspected, 18 nonconforming (from a delivery of 2,000) |
| Requirement | Bore Ø12 H7, free of burrs |
| Actual | Burrs on the bore edge on 18 of 50 parts; diameter within tolerance |
| Severity | Major |
| Containment | Lot 2391 blocked in the incoming area; supplier informed to block stock |
| Disposition | 100 % sorting by the supplier at our site; nonconforming parts returned |
| Corrective action | Yes: SCAR-2026-031, 8D requested by 27 October |
| Closure | Open until the 8D is accepted |
From NCR to corrective action
Not every NCR needs a full root-cause analysis. Decide by severity and repetition:
- Minor, one-off, cause obvious: correct, document, close.
- Major, critical or repeated: request corrective action. For a supplier problem, send a SCAR and require an 8D; for an internal problem, start an internal 8D.
Supplier NCRs also feed the supplier evaluation: their number, severity and how quickly they were closed are part of the supplier’s score.
What auditors look for
ISO 9001 (clause 8.7) requires nonconforming outputs to be identified and controlled, and records of the nonconformity, the actions taken, any concessions and the authority that decided. Typical findings: no record of who approved a “use as is”, nonconforming parts not clearly segregated, and NCRs never analysed for repeat problems.
Example: severity definitions
There is no single correct definition. Severity is a matter of interpretation and differs by quality department, project and industry; what matters is that yours is written down and applied the same way every time. A common starting point:
| Severity | Typical definition | Typical reaction |
|---|---|---|
| Critical | Can affect safety, function or regulatory compliance; the part cannot be used; or the defect reached your customer | Block stock immediately, inform the customer if affected, SCAR with 8D, containment within 24 hours |
| Major | The part does not meet a drawing or specification requirement and cannot be used as delivered, but safety and function are not at risk; rework or sorting is needed | SCAR with 8D, containment within 48 hours |
| Minor | A deviation that does not affect fit, form or function, such as cosmetic defects or missing or incorrect documentation that can be corrected | Record, correct, ask for corrective action if it repeats |
In aerospace and defence, check your customer’s definitions first and align yours with them. In our scoring model, these three levels lower the supplier’s score in the affected area by 15, 8 and 3 points.
FAQ
What is the difference between an NCR and a CAR?
The NCR records the nonconformity and what happens to the affected parts. A corrective action request (CAR, or SCAR for a supplier) asks for the root cause to be found and removed so it does not happen again.
Who can approve “use as is”?
Whoever your procedure defines, usually quality together with engineering; for products to aerospace or other regulated customers, often the customer or design authority. Record the approval on the NCR.
Do I need an NCR for every defect?
For every nonconforming product that is detected, yes, at least a short record. The depth of the follow-up (none, correction, or full 8D) depends on severity and repetition.