Practical guide
Supplier evaluation criteria: what to evaluate and how to score it
Supplier evaluation criteria explained one by one: what each criterion measures, how to score 0, 50 and 100, typical weights and which data to use.
Good supplier evaluation criteria predict whether a supplier will cause you problems, and they can be scored the same way by different people. Below are the 15 criteria we use, grouped in four areas, each with what it measures, how to score it and where the data comes from. They are also built into the calculator and the Excel template.
Product and service quality (50 % of the score)
| Criterion | Weight | 100 points | 50 points | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sample quality | 13.34 % | First samples / first article inspection met all requirements | Minor deviations, accepted after correction | Samples rejected |
| Material certificates | 13.34 % | Complete, correct certificates (e.g. EN 10204 3.1) with every delivery | Occasionally missing or incomplete | Regularly missing |
| References | 13.34 % | Proven experience with comparable parts, materials or industries | Some related experience | No relevant experience |
| Technical capability | 10 % | Equipment, processes and know-how fully match your requirements and tolerances | Capable with limitations | Not capable without investment |
Data: first article inspection reports, incoming inspection, certificates, visits, references.
Quality system (20 %)
| Criterion | Weight | 100 points | 50 points | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Certified management system | 5 % | Valid ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 (or AS/EN 9100 where required) | ISO 9001 only, or certification in progress | None |
| Supplier audit result | 5 % | Audit without major findings | Findings with an agreed action plan | Major findings not addressed |
| Site visit | 5 % | Orderly, organised, sufficient capacity | Acceptable with weaknesses | Serious concerns |
| Feedback from their other customers | 5 % | Consistently positive | Mixed | Negative |
Data: certificates (check validity and scope), audit reports, visit notes, references.
Delivery and cooperation (15 %)
| Criterion | Weight | How to score |
|---|---|---|
| On-time delivery | 5 % | The on-time delivery percentage itself: 96 % on time = 96 points |
| Payment terms | 3.33 % | 100 if the supplier’s terms match your policy, lower if not |
| Complaint handling | 3.33 % | Speed and quality of responses to your complaints |
| Communication | 3.33 % | Responsiveness, proactive information about delays or changes |
Data: ERP or purchasing records for delivery dates; the judgement of purchasing and quality for the rest.
Non-conformances (15 %, calculated)
These three criteria are not scored by hand; they are calculated from the non-conformances of the evaluation period:
| Criterion | Weight | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Number and severity of non-conformances | 6 % | 100 − (3 × critical + 2 × major + 1 × minor) × 10, minimum 0 |
| Non-conformances closed on time | 5 % | Share closed by the deadline; no non-conformances = 100 |
| 8D response quality | 4 % | Share with a complete 8D report (D1–D7); no non-conformances = 100 |
In addition, each non-conformance lowers the score of the area it affected: 15 points per critical, 8 per major and 3 per minor non-conformance, at most 30 per area, spread over that area’s criteria by weight. The supplier evaluation guide shows a worked example.
How to choose and weight your own criteria
- Fewer is better. Ten to fifteen criteria that people can score consistently beat forty that nobody fills in properly.
- Weight by impact. Product quality should carry the largest share; a supplier with perfect paperwork and defective parts is still a bad supplier.
- Use data where it exists. On-time delivery and non-conformances should come from records, not opinions.
- Write the scoring guidance down. “What does 50 points mean?” must have the same answer for every evaluator.
- Adapt to the supplier type. For a calibration lab or a service provider, set criteria that do not apply (such as material certificates) to 0 and redistribute their weight.
The 10 C’s and other frameworks
The 10 C’s of supplier evaluation (competency, capacity, commitment, control, cash, cost, consistency, culture, clean, communication) are a good checklist for selecting a new supplier, especially for strategic purchases. For the regular evaluation that ISO 9001 requires, measurable criteria like the ones above work better, because they can be scored the same way every year and connected to your non-conformance data.
FAQ
What are the most important supplier evaluation criteria?
Quality (samples, certificates, non-conformances), delivery reliability and the supplier’s ability to fix problems (complaint handling, 8D quality). Price belongs in supplier selection and negotiation, rather than in the quality evaluation.
Should price be a criterion?
Many companies keep price out of the quality evaluation and handle it in purchasing decisions. If you include it, give it a small weight, so a cheap supplier cannot compensate for poor quality.
Can different suppliers have different criteria?
Yes, as long as you define which criteria and weights apply to which supplier type in advance, and apply them consistently.