Free template
Supplier evaluation examples: an A, a B and a C supplier
Three filled-in supplier evaluation examples (A, B and C grade) with scores, non-conformance deductions, the resulting decision and the actions taken.
These supplier evaluation examples show three typical suppliers scored with the same 15 weighted criteria: one excellent, one good with weak spots, one unsatisfactory. Each shows the scores, how non-conformances changed the result, and what the evaluation led to. The suppliers are fictional; the numbers are calculated with the same model as the calculator, so you can reproduce every result.
Summary
| Supplier A: steel stockholder | Supplier B: machined parts | Supplier C: coating subcontractor | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Product / service quality (max. 50) | 47.69 | 42.01 | 34.43 |
| Quality system (max. 20) | 18.50 | 16.75 | 12.00 |
| Delivery and cooperation (max. 15) | 14.17 | 11.94 | 10.78 |
| Non-conformances (max. 15) | 15.00 | 8.70 | 5.40 |
| Total score | 95.36 | 79.40 | 62.61 |
| Grade | A | B | C |
Example 1: Supplier A (95.36, grade A)
A steel stockholder supplying bar stock with 3.1 certificates.
| Group | Scores |
|---|---|
| Product / service quality | samples 100, certificates 100, references 90, technical capability 90 |
| Quality system | ISO 9001 + 14001 100, audit 90, site visit 90, customer feedback 90 |
| Delivery and cooperation | on time 97 %, payment terms 100, complaint handling 90, communication 90 |
| Non-conformances | none in the period: 100 / 100 / 100 |
Decision: approval confirmed for another year. Supplier considered first for new bar stock requirements. Result shared with the supplier as a short scorecard.
Example 2: Supplier B (79.40, grade B)
A machining supplier for turned and milled parts.
| Group | Scores |
|---|---|
| Product / service quality | samples 90, certificates 100, references 80, technical capability 70 |
| Quality system | certification 100, audit 85, site visit 80, customer feedback 70 |
| Delivery and cooperation | on time 88 %, payment terms 100, complaint handling 60, communication 70 |
| Non-conformances | 1 major (product, closed on time, complete 8D), 1 minor (delivery, closed late, no 8D) |
Without non-conformances the supplier would have scored 86.83. The major non-conformance cost the product criteria 8 points in total; the minor one cost the delivery criteria 3 points; the calculated criteria dropped to 70, 50 and 50.
Decision: approval confirmed. Improvement agreed for the three weakest points: on-time delivery (target 95 %), complaint handling (8D for every non-conformance) and technical capability for the tighter tolerances of the next generation of parts. Review at the next evaluation.
Example 3: Supplier C (62.61, grade C)
A subcontractor for surface coating.
| Group | Scores |
|---|---|
| Product / service quality | samples 70, certificates 80, references 70, technical capability 80 |
| Quality system | ISO 9001 only 50, audit 60, site visit 70, customer feedback 60 |
| Delivery and cooperation | on time 78 %, payment terms 100, complaint handling 50, communication 60 |
| Non-conformances | 1 critical (product, closed late, complete 8D), 1 major (product, closed late, no 8D), 1 minor (delivery, closed on time, no 8D) |
The two product non-conformances together cost the product criteria 23 points; the calculated criteria are 40, 33.33 and 33.33.
Decision: approval set to conditional. Corrective action plan requested within four weeks, 100 % incoming inspection of coating thickness until three consecutive good lots, and qualification of a second coating supplier started. Re-evaluation after six months instead of twelve.
What the examples show
- Non-conformances make the difference. Supplier B looks like a solid 87 on questionnaire scores alone; two non-conformances bring it to 79 and show exactly where it needs to improve.
- The grade leads to a concrete decision. Confirmed approval, an improvement agreement, or conditional approval with a deadline.
- Every decision is documented with the reason and the next step, which is what ISO 9001 and AS/EN 9100 auditors look for.
Try it yourself
- Enter these examples in the supplier evaluation calculator and download the PDF.
- Use the Excel template for your own suppliers.
- Read the supplier evaluation guide for the method behind the numbers.