Free template

Supplier evaluation examples: an A, a B and a C supplier

Three filled-in supplier evaluation examples (A, B and C grade) with scores, non-conformance deductions, the resulting decision and the actions taken.

Written by , Head of Quality (AS/EN 9100)

Updated:

Ready immediatelyDownload at no cost
Editable filesAdapt it to your own process
Guidance includedGet practical notes on using it

These supplier evaluation examples show three typical suppliers scored with the same 15 weighted criteria: one excellent, one good with weak spots, one unsatisfactory. Each shows the scores, how non-conformances changed the result, and what the evaluation led to. The suppliers are fictional; the numbers are calculated with the same model as the calculator, so you can reproduce every result.

Summary

Supplier A: steel stockholder Supplier B: machined parts Supplier C: coating subcontractor
Product / service quality (max. 50) 47.69 42.01 34.43
Quality system (max. 20) 18.50 16.75 12.00
Delivery and cooperation (max. 15) 14.17 11.94 10.78
Non-conformances (max. 15) 15.00 8.70 5.40
Total score 95.36 79.40 62.61
Grade A B C

Example 1: Supplier A (95.36, grade A)

A steel stockholder supplying bar stock with 3.1 certificates.

Group Scores
Product / service quality samples 100, certificates 100, references 90, technical capability 90
Quality system ISO 9001 + 14001 100, audit 90, site visit 90, customer feedback 90
Delivery and cooperation on time 97 %, payment terms 100, complaint handling 90, communication 90
Non-conformances none in the period: 100 / 100 / 100

Decision: approval confirmed for another year. Supplier considered first for new bar stock requirements. Result shared with the supplier as a short scorecard.

Example 2: Supplier B (79.40, grade B)

A machining supplier for turned and milled parts.

Group Scores
Product / service quality samples 90, certificates 100, references 80, technical capability 70
Quality system certification 100, audit 85, site visit 80, customer feedback 70
Delivery and cooperation on time 88 %, payment terms 100, complaint handling 60, communication 70
Non-conformances 1 major (product, closed on time, complete 8D), 1 minor (delivery, closed late, no 8D)

Without non-conformances the supplier would have scored 86.83. The major non-conformance cost the product criteria 8 points in total; the minor one cost the delivery criteria 3 points; the calculated criteria dropped to 70, 50 and 50.

Decision: approval confirmed. Improvement agreed for the three weakest points: on-time delivery (target 95 %), complaint handling (8D for every non-conformance) and technical capability for the tighter tolerances of the next generation of parts. Review at the next evaluation.

Example 3: Supplier C (62.61, grade C)

A subcontractor for surface coating.

Group Scores
Product / service quality samples 70, certificates 80, references 70, technical capability 80
Quality system ISO 9001 only 50, audit 60, site visit 70, customer feedback 60
Delivery and cooperation on time 78 %, payment terms 100, complaint handling 50, communication 60
Non-conformances 1 critical (product, closed late, complete 8D), 1 major (product, closed late, no 8D), 1 minor (delivery, closed on time, no 8D)

The two product non-conformances together cost the product criteria 23 points; the calculated criteria are 40, 33.33 and 33.33.

Decision: approval set to conditional. Corrective action plan requested within four weeks, 100 % incoming inspection of coating thickness until three consecutive good lots, and qualification of a second coating supplier started. Re-evaluation after six months instead of twelve.

What the examples show

  • Non-conformances make the difference. Supplier B looks like a solid 87 on questionnaire scores alone; two non-conformances bring it to 79 and show exactly where it needs to improve.
  • The grade leads to a concrete decision. Confirmed approval, an improvement agreement, or conditional approval with a deadline.
  • Every decision is documented with the reason and the next step, which is what ISO 9001 and AS/EN 9100 auditors look for.

Try it yourself