Practical guide

Supplier evaluation process: step by step

The supplier evaluation process step by step: scope, criteria, data, scoring, decisions and records, with responsibilities and what auditors check.

Written by , Head of Quality (AS/EN 9100)

Updated:

Grounded in practiceWritten for real quality work
Ready to applyUse examples, templates, and clear steps
Useful next stepsConnected to relevant tools and guides

The supplier evaluation process turns data about your suppliers into documented decisions: who stays approved, who needs to improve, who is replaced. This page describes the process as a procedure you can adopt: steps, responsibilities, inputs and records. The method behind it (criteria, weights, grades) is explained in the supplier evaluation guide.

Process overview

Step Responsible Input Output / record
1. Define scope and frequency Quality manager Supplier list, product risk List of suppliers to evaluate, schedule
2. Collect data Quality, purchasing, logistics NCRs, delivery data, audit reports Data per supplier for the period
3. Score Evaluation team Data, criteria with scoring guidance Completed evaluation form
4. Grade and decide Quality manager with purchasing Score, grade limits Grade A/B/C, decision on approval status
5. Act Purchasing / quality Decision Actions with dates, supplier informed
6. Update the approved supplier list Quality manager Decision Updated list with status and date
7. Follow up Quality manager Agreed actions Verified actions, next evaluation date

1. Define scope and frequency

Evaluate every supplier whose products or services affect the quality of your product: raw material and parts, outsourced processes (heat treatment, coating, machining), and services such as calibration or testing. Office supplies do not need an evaluation.

Set the frequency by risk: at least yearly for suppliers that affect product quality, plus an extra evaluation after a critical non-conformance or a significant change at the supplier (new site, new owner, process change).

2. Collect the data

Most of the effort is here, and most of it can be automated:

  • Non-conformances of the period, with severity, affected area, whether closed on time and whether the 8D was complete: from your complaint records.
  • Delivery reliability: on-time deliveries / all deliveries, from purchasing or ERP.
  • Audit results and site visits: from audit reports.
  • Qualitative judgements (communication, complaint handling): from the people who work with the supplier, ideally two people per supplier.

3. Score

Use one form for all suppliers, with scoring guidance for each criterion so different evaluators score the same way. See supplier evaluation criteria for guidance on 0, 50 and 100 points. The template or the calculator does the arithmetic.

4. Grade and decide

Translate the score into a grade with limits you defined in advance (for example A ≥ 90, B 71–89, C ≤ 70) and decide the approval status: approved, conditionally approved or blocked. Purchasing should be part of this step; a decision that purchasing does not support will not be applied.

5. Act

  • A: confirm the approval.
  • B: agree on improvements for the weakest criteria, with dates.
  • C: request a corrective action plan, set the approval to conditional, increase incoming inspection, start qualifying an alternative if nothing improves.

Inform every supplier of the result. A one-page scorecard is enough.

6. Update the approved supplier list

The approved supplier list shows the current status of each supplier with the date and basis of the decision. Under AS/EN 9100 it is expected to include the scope of approval, for example which processes or products the supplier is approved for.

7. Follow up

Check that the agreed actions happened, and plan the next evaluation. Unfinished actions from the last evaluation are the first thing to look at in the next one.

Records to keep

ISO 9001 requires documented information of the evaluation and of the actions arising from it. Keep at least:

  • the procedure (criteria, weights, grade limits, frequency),
  • the completed evaluation per supplier and period,
  • the decisions and actions, with dates and responsible persons,
  • the approved supplier list with its history.

What auditors check

  • Are the criteria defined before the evaluation and applied consistently?

  • Are all relevant suppliers evaluated, including service providers and outsourced processes?

  • Do poor results lead to actions, and are those actions followed up?

  • Does the approved supplier list match the evaluation results?

  • Are non-conformances reflected in the evaluation?

  • Was every supplier on the list given an initial assessment before approval?

  • Who evaluates? Auditors ask whether the person doing the evaluation works with the supplier and has the data: non-conformances, delivery dates kept, quality of parts and documents.

  • Do the criteria fit the supplier category, or is a service provider scored like a raw material supplier?

FAQ

Who owns the supplier evaluation process?

Usually quality management, with purchasing and logistics delivering data and sharing the decision. What matters is that one person is responsible for running it on time.

Can the process be automated?

The data collection and arithmetic, yes: non-conformances and delivery data can lower the score automatically, and the approved supplier list can follow the grade. The decision and the dialogue with the supplier remain people’s work. That is the split Suppliscore is built on.