Free template

Supplier scorecard: metrics, layout and example

How to build a supplier scorecard: which metrics to include, how to weight them, a one-page layout to share with suppliers, and an example.

Written by , Head of Quality (AS/EN 9100)

Updated:

Ready immediatelyDownload at no cost
Editable filesAdapt it to your own process
Guidance includedGet practical notes on using it
XLSExcel workbook · XLSXFree download

Supplier scorecard template

Score and grade against the previous period, on-time delivery, ppm, on-time closure and 8D quality with targets, strengths and expected improvements. Formulas included.

No signup required

A supplier scorecard is a one-page summary of a supplier’s performance that you share with the supplier: the overall score and grade, the key metrics, how they developed, and what you expect to improve. The internal supplier evaluation produces the numbers; the scorecard is how you communicate them.

What a good supplier scorecard contains

Section Content
Header Supplier, period, date, your contact
Overall result Total score (0–100) and grade (A/B/C), compared with the previous period
Quality metrics Number of non-conformances by severity, parts per million (ppm) rejected, share of non-conformances closed on time, share with complete 8D
Delivery metrics On-time delivery %, quantity accuracy
Cooperation Complaint handling, communication (scored)
Strengths Two or three things that went well
Expected improvements The two or three weakest points, with targets and dates

Keep it to one page. A supplier will act on three clear points, not on twenty.

Supplier scorecard metrics (KPIs)

Metric Formula Typical target
On-time delivery (OTD) deliveries on the confirmed date / all deliveries ≥ 95 %
ppm rejected parts / delivered parts × 1,000,000 depends on industry and part
Non-conformances count by severity in the period 0 critical
On-time closure non-conformances closed by the deadline / all 100 %
8D quality non-conformances with complete 8D (D1–D7) / all 100 %

Targets differ by industry; agree them with the supplier, ideally in the quality agreement, so the scorecard measures against something the supplier accepted.

Example scorecard (summary)

Supplier Machined parts supplier (example)
Period January–December
Score / grade 79.4 / B (previous period: 84.1 / B)
Non-conformances 0 critical, 1 major, 1 minor
On-time delivery 88 % (target 95 %)
On-time closure / 8D 50 % / 50 % (target 100 % / 100 %)
Strengths Certificates always complete; first samples accepted without correction
Expected improvements 1. OTD ≥ 95 % by Q2. 2. 8D report for every non-conformance. 3. Capability study for the tighter tolerances of part family X by Q3.

The numbers come from the B supplier in our supplier evaluation examples; the previous-period value is illustrative.

Scorecard vs. supplier evaluation

Supplier evaluation Supplier scorecard
Audience Internal (quality, purchasing) The supplier
Content All criteria, weights, internal judgements Key metrics, result, expectations
Purpose Decision: approval status, actions Communication: what to improve
Requirement ISO 9001 8.4.1, AS/EN 9100 Good practice

Build your own

FAQ

How often should I send a supplier scorecard?

As often as you evaluate: yearly for most suppliers, quarterly for critical or high-volume suppliers, and after a re-evaluation following a serious problem.

Should the scorecard show the supplier’s rank among other suppliers?

Usually not by name. Showing the supplier’s grade and how it compares with targets is enough; ranking against named competitors can harm the relationship.