Free template
Supplier scorecard: metrics, layout and example
How to build a supplier scorecard: which metrics to include, how to weight them, a one-page layout to share with suppliers, and an example.
Supplier scorecard template
Score and grade against the previous period, on-time delivery, ppm, on-time closure and 8D quality with targets, strengths and expected improvements. Formulas included.
No signup requiredA supplier scorecard is a one-page summary of a supplier’s performance that you share with the supplier: the overall score and grade, the key metrics, how they developed, and what you expect to improve. The internal supplier evaluation produces the numbers; the scorecard is how you communicate them.
What a good supplier scorecard contains
| Section | Content |
|---|---|
| Header | Supplier, period, date, your contact |
| Overall result | Total score (0–100) and grade (A/B/C), compared with the previous period |
| Quality metrics | Number of non-conformances by severity, parts per million (ppm) rejected, share of non-conformances closed on time, share with complete 8D |
| Delivery metrics | On-time delivery %, quantity accuracy |
| Cooperation | Complaint handling, communication (scored) |
| Strengths | Two or three things that went well |
| Expected improvements | The two or three weakest points, with targets and dates |
Keep it to one page. A supplier will act on three clear points, not on twenty.
Supplier scorecard metrics (KPIs)
| Metric | Formula | Typical target |
|---|---|---|
| On-time delivery (OTD) | deliveries on the confirmed date / all deliveries | ≥ 95 % |
| ppm | rejected parts / delivered parts × 1,000,000 | depends on industry and part |
| Non-conformances | count by severity in the period | 0 critical |
| On-time closure | non-conformances closed by the deadline / all | 100 % |
| 8D quality | non-conformances with complete 8D (D1–D7) / all | 100 % |
Targets differ by industry; agree them with the supplier, ideally in the quality agreement, so the scorecard measures against something the supplier accepted.
Example scorecard (summary)
| Supplier | Machined parts supplier (example) |
| Period | January–December |
| Score / grade | 79.4 / B (previous period: 84.1 / B) |
| Non-conformances | 0 critical, 1 major, 1 minor |
| On-time delivery | 88 % (target 95 %) |
| On-time closure / 8D | 50 % / 50 % (target 100 % / 100 %) |
| Strengths | Certificates always complete; first samples accepted without correction |
| Expected improvements | 1. OTD ≥ 95 % by Q2. 2. 8D report for every non-conformance. 3. Capability study for the tighter tolerances of part family X by Q3. |
The numbers come from the B supplier in our supplier evaluation examples; the previous-period value is illustrative.
Scorecard vs. supplier evaluation
| Supplier evaluation | Supplier scorecard | |
|---|---|---|
| Audience | Internal (quality, purchasing) | The supplier |
| Content | All criteria, weights, internal judgements | Key metrics, result, expectations |
| Purpose | Decision: approval status, actions | Communication: what to improve |
| Requirement | ISO 9001 8.4.1, AS/EN 9100 | Good practice |
Build your own
- Score the supplier with the calculator or the Excel template; the PDF report from the calculator can serve as a simple scorecard.
- Use the criteria guide to decide which metrics to show.
- For scorecards that update automatically from your non-conformance and delivery data, see supplier evaluation software.
FAQ
How often should I send a supplier scorecard?
As often as you evaluate: yearly for most suppliers, quarterly for critical or high-volume suppliers, and after a re-evaluation following a serious problem.
Should the scorecard show the supplier’s rank among other suppliers?
Usually not by name. Showing the supplier’s grade and how it compares with targets is enough; ranking against named competitors can harm the relationship.