Practical guide
Non-conformance management: process, dispositions and ISO requirements
Non-conformance management step by step: identify, segregate, decide the disposition and prevent recurrence, with ISO 9001, AS9100 and IATF requirements.
Non-conformance management is how a company handles anything that does not meet requirements: a part out of tolerance, a missing certificate, a wrong delivery, a process step skipped. Done well, it does two things: it stops the nonconforming product from reaching the customer, and it makes sure the same problem does not come back.
This page covers the whole process, the dispositions you can choose, what the standards require, and how supplier non-conformances fit in.
The non-conformance process
| Step | What happens | Record |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Identify | Someone finds a non-conformity: incoming inspection, production, final inspection, customer, audit | Initial report |
| 2. Document | Describe what, where, how many, against which requirement | Non-conformance report (NCR) |
| 3. Segregate and contain | Label and separate the parts, block stock, check other lots and parts in transit | Blocked stock, containment actions |
| 4. Evaluate and decide the disposition | Decide what happens to the product (below) | Disposition with approval |
| 5. Correct | Carry out the disposition: rework, scrap, return | Evidence of the correction |
| 6. Decide on corrective action | Is a root cause analysis needed? For serious or repeated problems: yes | Corrective action or 8D report |
| 7. Close and analyse | Close the NCR, review trends regularly | Closed NCR, trend report |
The two halves are often confused: steps 3–5 deal with the product (ISO 9001 clause 8.7, control of nonconforming outputs); step 6 deals with the cause (clause 10.2, nonconformity and corrective action).
Dispositions: what to do with nonconforming product
| Disposition | Meaning | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Rework | Bring the product into full conformity with the requirements | Re-inspect after rework |
| Repair | Make the product usable, but not fully conforming | Requires approval; in aerospace by the design authority, often the customer |
| Use as is / concession | Accept the deviation without change | Requires approval and a record; often the customer must agree |
| Regrade | Use for a different application where it conforms | Clear identification needed |
| Return to supplier | Send back for replacement or rework at the supplier | Link to the supplier complaint |
| Scrap | Destroy the product | Make it unusable so it cannot re-enter the process |
Decide who may approve each disposition and write it down. “Use as is” decided by the production supervisor under delivery pressure is a classic audit finding.
What the standards require
- ISO 9001 clause 8.7: nonconforming outputs must be identified and controlled to prevent unintended use or delivery. Allowed actions include correction, segregation and containment, informing the customer, and acceptance under concession. Records must describe the non-conformity, the actions taken, any concessions and who decided.
- ISO 9001 clause 10.2: react to the non-conformity, evaluate the need to eliminate its causes, implement actions, review their effectiveness and update risks and the QMS where needed.
- AS/EN 9100 adds that “use as is” and “repair” dispositions need approval by the organisation responsible for the design, that scrapped product must be conspicuously and permanently marked or controlled until rendered unusable, and that nonconforming product delivered must be reported to customers and, where relevant, to the supplier.
- IATF 16949 adds requirements for customer authorisation of concessions, control of reworked and repaired product, and problem-solving methods. In IATF certification audits, findings are graded as major (for example a total breakdown of a required process, or a non-conformity likely to result in nonconforming product being shipped) or minor.
- ISO 13485 requires documented procedures for nonconforming product, including product found after delivery, and rework according to documented instructions with re-verification.
Supplier non-conformances
When the non-conformity comes from a supplier, the internal process continues into the supplier relationship:
- Contain at your site, at the supplier and in transit.
- Inform the supplier quickly with a clear description and evidence.
- Request a corrective action with deadlines: a corrective action request (SCAR) answered with an 8D report.
- Agree the disposition and the costs (sorting, rework, replacement).
- Close only when the supplier’s corrective action is verified.
- Feed the result into the supplier evaluation: the number, severity and on-time closure of non-conformances are the most objective evidence of a supplier’s quality.
The process is described in detail in supplier complaint management.
Severity classes
Classify every non-conformance by severity; it decides the reaction and the weight in supplier evaluation:
| Severity | Typical definition | Typical reaction |
|---|---|---|
| Critical | Safety, legal or function affected; or the defect reached the customer | Immediate containment, 8D, customer informed |
| Major | Fit or function impaired, product unusable without action | Containment, root cause analysis |
| Minor | Deviation without effect on fit, function or safety (e.g. marking, documentation) | Correction, trend monitoring |
Measure it
Useful indicators for non-conformance management: number of NCRs by source and severity, cost of nonconformance, share of NCRs closed on time, average time to closure, and recurrence of the same root cause. For suppliers, the same data becomes supplier KPIs.
FAQ
What is the difference between a non-conformance and a nonconformity?
They mean the same thing: the non-fulfilment of a requirement. ISO standards use “nonconformity”; in industry, “non-conformance” and NCR are common.
What is the difference between ISO 9001 clauses 8.7 and 10.2?
Clause 8.7 deals with the nonconforming product itself (identify, segregate, decide what to do with it). Clause 10.2 deals with the cause (analyse it and take corrective action so it does not recur).
Who can approve a “use as is” disposition?
Someone with the authority defined in your procedure, usually quality together with engineering. If the deviation affects the customer’s requirements, the customer must agree; in aerospace, the design authority must approve.