Practical guide
Supplier KPIs: the metrics that matter, with formulas and an example
The supplier KPIs that matter: on-time delivery, PPM, non-conformances and 8D response, with formulas, a worked example and target values.
Supplier KPIs (key performance indicators) turn a supplier’s performance into numbers you can compare over time and between suppliers: how reliably they deliver, how many defective parts they send, and how well they react when something goes wrong. Good KPIs are the factual basis of supplier evaluation; without them, an evaluation is an opinion.
This page lists the KPIs that are worth tracking, how to calculate each one, where the data comes from and what values are typical. A worked example at the end shows the numbers for one supplier over a year.
The core supplier KPIs
| KPI | Formula | Data source | Typical target |
|---|---|---|---|
| On-time delivery (OTD) | On-time deliveries ÷ all deliveries × 100 | ERP goods receipts vs. confirmed date | ≥ 95 % |
| On-time in full (OTIF) | Deliveries on time and in full quantity ÷ all deliveries × 100 | ERP | ≥ 95 % |
| PPM (defective parts per million) | Rejected parts ÷ delivered parts × 1,000,000 | Incoming inspection, NCRs | Depends on industry: < 50 in automotive series, a few hundred to a few thousand in low-volume machining |
| Lot acceptance rate | Accepted lots ÷ inspected lots × 100 | Incoming inspection | ≥ 98 % |
| Number and severity of non-conformances | Count per period, split critical / major / minor | NCR records | Trend down; zero critical |
| Non-conformances closed on time | NCs closed by the deadline ÷ all NCs due × 100 | NCR / 8D records | ≥ 90 % |
| 8D response quality | NCs with a complete 8D (D1–D7) ÷ NCs requiring an 8D × 100 | 8D reports | 100 % |
| Response time | Days from complaint to containment (D3) and to root cause (D4) | 8D reports | Containment ≤ 1–2 days |
| Cost of poor quality (supplier-caused) | Sorting, rework, scrap and admin costs caused by the supplier | Cost records, debit notes | Trend down |
Pick a small set. For most manufacturing companies, OTD, PPM (or lot acceptance), non-conformances and on-time closure cover 80 % of what matters. A dozen KPIs nobody reviews are worth less than four that drive decisions.
How to calculate them correctly
On-time delivery
OTD looks simple, but three definitions decide the result:
- Which date counts? Use the date the supplier confirmed, not the date you originally requested; otherwise you measure your own planning.
- What is “on time”? Define a window, for example 3 days early to 0 days late. Deliveries that arrive too early can be a problem too (storage, cash).
- What is counted? Per order line or per delivery? Per line is stricter and more meaningful when deliveries contain several items.
Write the definition into your procedure. Changing it later breaks the trend.
PPM
PPM counts parts, not deliveries: 1 bad part in a delivery of 10,000 is 100 PPM. Count every part you rejected because of the supplier (at incoming inspection, in production and at your customer), and use the delivered quantity of the same period as the denominator.
For low volumes (a few hundred parts a year), PPM jumps wildly: one rejected part out of 400 is 2,500 PPM. Use the lot acceptance rate or the number of non-conformances instead, or report PPM over a rolling 12 months.
Non-conformance KPIs
The number of non-conformances alone is misleading: a critical defect that reached your customer is not the same as a wrong label. Count them by severity, and track how the supplier handles them: closure on time and 8D completeness show whether the supplier fixes problems or just answers them. These three are calculated automatically from the records in the supplier evaluation model used on this site.
From KPIs to an evaluation
KPIs are measurements; the evaluation is a decision. To get from one to the other, translate each KPI into a score with a rule you define in advance, then weight it:
| KPI | Example scoring rule (0–100) |
|---|---|
| OTD | Score = OTD in %, so 96 % OTD = 96 |
| Non-conformances | 100 − (3 × critical + 2 × major + 1 × minor) × 10, minimum 0 |
| Closed on time | Score = share closed on time in % |
| 8D response quality | Score = share of complete 8D reports in % |
The weighted sum gives a total score and an A/B/C grade. You can try this with real numbers in the free supplier evaluation calculator or the Excel template. The default model has no separate PPM criterion: delivered quality enters through the non-conformances, which also capture severity. If PPM is your main quality measure, show it on the supplier scorecard next to the score.
Worked example: one supplier, one year
A machining supplier delivering housings over 12 months:
| Data | Value |
|---|---|
| Deliveries (order lines) | 210, of which 197 on time |
| Parts delivered | 48,000 |
| Parts rejected | 120 (in 3 lots) |
| Non-conformances | 0 critical, 1 major, 2 minor |
| Closed by the deadline | 2 of 3 |
| Complete 8D reports | 3 of 3 |
| KPI | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| OTD | 197 ÷ 210 × 100 | 93.8 % |
| PPM | 120 ÷ 48,000 × 1,000,000 | 2,500 PPM |
| Non-conformance score | 100 − (0 × 3 + 1 × 2 + 2 × 1) × 10 | 60 |
| Closed on time | 2 ÷ 3 × 100 | 66.7 % |
| 8D response quality | 3 ÷ 3 × 100 | 100 % |
Reading the numbers: delivery is slightly below a 95 % target, and the quality problems are not severe, but one non-conformance closed late. The useful conversation with this supplier is about on-time closure and delivery reliability, not about the 8D reports, which are fine. That is what KPIs are for: they tell you which conversation to have.
Common mistakes
- Measuring against the requested date instead of the confirmed date, so the supplier is blamed for your short lead times.
- PPM for tiny volumes, where one part swings the number by thousands.
- Counting non-conformances without severity.
- KPIs without consequences. If a supplier at 80 % OTD and one at 99 % are treated the same, nobody will look at the KPIs for long.
- Not sharing them. Suppliers improve what they see. Send each supplier their own numbers, at least once a year, ideally as a scorecard.
What the standards expect
ISO 9001 clause 8.4.1 requires you to monitor the performance of external providers and keep records; it does not prescribe KPIs. AS/EN 9100 is more specific: supplier performance must be reviewed periodically, including product conformity and on-time delivery. In an audit, KPIs are the easiest way to show that your supplier evaluation process is based on data, and that the results feed your approved supplier list. Where KPIs show a problem, a supplier audit is often the next step.
FAQ
What are the most important supplier KPIs?
On-time delivery, delivered quality (PPM or lot acceptance rate), the number and severity of non-conformances, and how reliably the supplier closes them on time.
How do you calculate supplier PPM?
Rejected parts divided by delivered parts in the same period, multiplied by 1,000,000. 120 rejected out of 48,000 delivered is 2,500 PPM.
What is a good on-time delivery rate?
Most manufacturers target 95 % or more against the confirmed date. In automotive series supply, 98 % or more is common.
How often should supplier KPIs be reviewed?
Monthly or quarterly for important suppliers, and in full at each periodic evaluation, usually once a year.