Practical guide
Supplier qualification: the approval process step by step
How to qualify and approve a new supplier: risk class, questionnaire, documents, samples, audit and the approval decision, with a checklist per step.
Supplier qualification is the process of proving, before you buy, that a new supplier can meet your requirements. It ends with an approval decision: the supplier is added to your approved supplier list, with a defined scope, or rejected. After approval, ongoing supplier evaluation checks whether the supplier keeps meeting the requirements.
| Qualification (approval) | Evaluation (re-evaluation) | |
|---|---|---|
| When | Before the first order | Periodically, e.g. yearly, and after serious problems |
| Question | Can the supplier meet our requirements? | Did the supplier meet them? |
| Evidence | Questionnaire, certificates, samples, audit | Delivery and quality data, non-conformances |
| Result | Approved (with scope), conditionally approved, rejected | Score and grade, status confirmed or changed |
The qualification process
| Step | What you do | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Classify the risk | Decide how critical the part or service is | Risk class (e.g. high / medium / low) |
| 2. Pre-qualify | Send a supplier questionnaire, check basic data | Completed questionnaire |
| 3. Check documents | Certificates, approvals, insurance, NDA | Copies with validity dates |
| 4. Assess capability | Technical review, references, capacity | Review notes |
| 5. Samples / first article | Test parts against the drawing | Sample or FAI report |
| 6. Audit (if required by risk) | On-site or remote process audit | Audit report |
| 7. Decide and record | Approve with scope, conditionally, or reject | Entry on the approved supplier list |
1. Classify the risk
Not every supplier needs the full process. The effort should match the risk to your product:
- High: parts that affect safety, function or regulatory compliance; special processes (heat treatment, welding, plating, NDT); single sources.
- Medium: standard parts made to your drawing, materials with certificate requirements.
- Low: catalogue parts, consumables, services without product impact.
A practical rule: high-risk suppliers go through all seven steps including an audit; medium-risk skip the audit unless the samples or the questionnaire raise doubts; low-risk need steps 2, 3 and 7.
2. Pre-qualify with a questionnaire
A self-assessment questionnaire filters out unsuitable suppliers cheaply: company data, certifications, main processes and equipment, quality organisation, sub-suppliers, capacity, references. Ask for evidence, not only yes/no answers: “Do you have a calibration system?” is less useful than “Attach your calibration list for measuring equipment used on our parts.”
3. Check documents
- Quality management certificate (ISO 9001, AS/EN 9100, IATF 16949, ISO 13485) with scope and expiry date; check the scope covers what you buy.
- Special process approvals (for example Nadcap in aerospace) and customer approvals where your customer requires them.
- Signed NDA if drawings are shared, insurance, and any legal or customer-specific declarations (REACH, RoHS, conflict minerals, export control).
4. Assess capability
Can the supplier actually make your part? A technical review of the drawing with the supplier’s engineers often reveals more than any questionnaire: tolerances they cannot hold, processes they would subcontract, measuring equipment they lack. Ask for references with comparable parts or customers.
5. Samples and first article inspection
Order samples or a first production lot and inspect them completely against the drawing and specification. In aerospace this is the first article inspection (FAI) according to AS/EN 9102; in automotive, the PPAP or the VDA PPF process. The result is the first hard evidence of what the supplier can do.
6. Audit, where the risk requires it
For high-risk suppliers, a process audit on site (or remote, if justified) checks that the system described in the questionnaire actually works. Use a structured supplier audit checklist so audits are comparable between suppliers.
7. Decide and record
Approve the supplier for a defined scope (which parts, processes or materials), conditionally (for example “approved for prototypes only” or “100 % incoming inspection for the first three lots”), or reject. Record the decision, the date, who decided and the evidence it was based on. That record is what an auditor will ask for.
After approval: from qualification to evaluation
Qualification is a snapshot. The first months of real deliveries tell you more than any audit, so plan an early evaluation, for example after three months or the first five lots, and then move the supplier into your regular supplier evaluation process. A scored evaluation with the same criteria for all suppliers makes the results comparable, and a supplier scorecard shares them with the supplier.
Qualification in regulated industries
- ISO 9001 (clause 8.4.1) requires criteria for the evaluation, selection, monitoring and re-evaluation of external providers, and records. It does not prescribe the steps above, but it expects you to apply your criteria before you buy.
- AS/EN 9100 adds a register of approved suppliers with status and scope, risk management for external providers, and requirements flowed down to the supplier, including FAI.
- Medical devices (ISO 13485, FDA): supplier controls must be proportionate to the risk the purchased product poses to the device, with documented evaluation and selection. The FDA’s quality system regulation now refers to ISO 13485 for these requirements.
- Pharma (GMP): suppliers of starting materials, active substances and packaging materials must be qualified before use, typically with an audit for critical materials, and approved by the quality unit.
Checklist: approving a new supplier
- Risk class defined and documented
- Questionnaire completed, with evidence attached
- Certificates checked: valid, scope matches
- NDA signed if drawings are shared
- Technical review of the drawing done
- Samples or first article inspected and accepted
- Audit done if the risk class requires it
- Approval decision with scope, date and responsible person recorded
- Supplier added to the approved supplier list
- Date for the first evaluation set
FAQ
What is the difference between supplier qualification and supplier approval?
Qualification is the process of collecting evidence; approval is the decision at its end. In practice the terms are often used interchangeably.
Do I need to audit every new supplier?
No. ISO 9001 and AS/EN 9100 expect the effort to match the risk. An audit is usual for high-risk suppliers and special processes; for low-risk suppliers, documents and a questionnaire are enough.
How long does supplier qualification take?
For a low-risk supplier, a few days. For a high-risk supplier with samples and an audit, typically one to three months, mostly waiting for samples.